Brendon is this what you hinted at

[Grockle]

Tweet

When you said you could see the canonical tag causing problems?

Problems with Google search results. Indexed entries down from 30,ooo to 2400 and falling! - Webmaster Help

[Brendon]

Heh, no. It's much, much worse than that. That example is just someone who misunderstood the tag, and implemented it incorrectly. Whilst it's another reason that the tag is a bad idea, it's not the main one